Cookie Girl Bake Shop seasonal offerings and specials

Featured Items

Cookie Girl Bake Shop

Our cookie bakery specializes in iced sugar cookie pops, custom-decorated cookie favors for parties, cookie bouquets in edible arrangements, and gift baskets of freshly baked cookies and brownies, and we feature seasonal offerings to accompany events and holidays throughout the year. No matter the occasion, our sweet treats are the sweetest way to celebrate!

Whether for individual party favors or party platters to feed a crowd, a gift for someone special, or to satiate those sweet-tooth cravings, we work to create beautiful and delicious scratch-made baked goods to compliment any theme. If you don’t see what you’re looking for, please contact us to discuss how we can make your cookie dreams come true!

Order online for delivery or store pickup, or visit our bake shop in New City, Rockland County NY.

Custom cookie pops and for parties
Cookie Pops & Favors

Always individually wrapped, our signature iced sugar cookies are perfect as party favors, and they can be ordered with or without lollipop sticks. We often hear that our cookies, crafted in small batches and meticulously hand-decorated, taste as good as they look!

We use high quality, all-natural ingredients, no preservatives, and lots of love in everything we bake. Our artists take great care in creating tailor-made cookies that are edible works of art. The possibilities for cookie design and layout are vast, and we work closely with clients who are looking for personalized custom themes. Click through to shop our basic designs, and please contact us if you are looking for something more!

Cookie bouquets for get well wish or congratulations
Themed Bouquets

For any and all occasions, a Cookie Girl themed cookie bouquet is sure to make a statement and sweeten anyone’s day. Bouquets can be hand-held wraps for one person, or tabletop standing arrangements, able to feed a larger group; we offer bouquets in various sizes and designs.

Whether congratulating someone for their outstanding role in a play, or sending warm wishes for a speedy recovery; saying ‘Welcome Home!’ or ‘Happy Birthday!’; ‘Hello!’ or just anything at all; we can customize a cookie bouquet to fit any event. Made-to-order from scratch, always fresh and impeccably hand-decorated, our themed cookie bouquets are memorable and delicious. We’re happy to work with you to create a version all your own! Special orders are welcome.

Cookie Girl gift baskets and boxes of scratch-baked cookies
Gift Baskets & Boxes

Beautifully wrapped and perfect for gifting, our cookie baskets and gift boxes come packaged to make a statement. Whether you are looking to feed a larger crowd, or gifting our baked goods to a single person, Cookie Girl offers a variety of options to fit the bill, no matter what purpose they’ll serve.

Opt for a gift basket with assorted classic cookies and brownies (aptly named the Crowd Pleaser) to bring to any occasion or gathering, and you’ll be a hit at the party! Choose a window box filled with iced sugar cookies, and your gift-recipient will never forget it. All of our gift boxes and baskets are full of freshly baked, scratch-made goodies, made to order, and assembled with lots of love by hand. Contact us if you are looking for different shapes and designs; we’re be happy to accommodate custom orders!

Our Specialties

  • Decorated Iced Sugar Cookie Pops & Brownie Pops
  • Classic Cookies Really Good Brownies Cupcakes
  • Deep Dish Chocolate Chip Cookie Cakes
  • Logo & Photo Cookies
  • Party Favors Centerpieces
  • Custom Bouquets & Gift Baskets
  • Cookie Dog All-Natural Dog Treats
Some items are available in-store only; contact us for more details.